--- title: "Reed VS Rosenthal - PhalloBoards - Phalloboards" description: "Hey guys, I'm really considering to get lengthening and thickening procedures done and I've narrowed down my choices to either Dr. Harold Reed or Dr. Brian..." url: "https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/general-phalloplasty-discussion-archive/6978635-reed-vs-rosenthal.html" date: "2026-08-07T17:51:45+00:00" language: "en-GB" --- PhalloBoards - An Online Community to Discuss Penile Girth Enhancement General Forum Doctors Forum Username Password Remember me - [ Forgot your password? ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/component/users/reset.html?Itemid=101) - [ Forgot your username? ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/component/users/remind.html?Itemid=101) - [ Create an account ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) # TOPIC: Reed VS Rosenthal ## Reed VS Rosenthal 12 years 4 weeks ago [\#1283477540](#1283477540) - **[dba256](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html "View dba256's Profile")** - [![dba256's Avatar](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html "View dba256's Profile") Topic Author - [ Offline](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html) - General - ![General](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/ranks/rank1.gif) - Posts: 2 - Thanks: 0 - [ ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/pms.html?task=new&recip=3184854) Hey guys,I'm really considering to get lengthening and thickening procedures done and I've narrowed down my choices to either Dr. Harold Reed or Dr. Brian Rosenthal. I wanted to know if any of you had any experience with these procedures done by these doctors or know of anyone who has? I'm having a little trouble deciding and I want to make sure I'm making the best choice, hope someone can help. Please [Log in](https://j4.phalloboards.info/login.html?return=aHR0cHM6Ly9qNC5waGFsbG9ib2FyZHMuaW5mby9nZW5lcmFsLWZvcnVtL2dlbmVyYWwtcGhhbGxvcGxhc3R5LWRpc2N1c3Npb24tYXJjaGl2ZS82OTc4NjM1LXJlZWQtdnMtcm9zZW50aGFsLmh0bWw/bWFya2Rvd249MQ==) or [Create an account](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) to join the conversation. ## Re: Reed VS Rosenthal 12 years 4 weeks ago [\#1283477821](#1283477821) - - !['s Avatar](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg) - Pending Email Verification - ![Pending Email Verification](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/ranks/rank2.gif) - Thanks: 0 - [ ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/pms.html?task=new&recip=1867342) Hey dba, I went to Reed 20 years ago almost. I like him a lot as he is cautious. I had dermal fat grafts and lengthening. It was done at the same time, something that is not done anymore - you need to have 2 separate procedures. He doesn't do DFG anymore either - I am not sure anyone does as they don't last for a lot of people. I don't know anything about Rosenthal but would definitely recommend Reed as competent and not a hack. Please [Log in](https://j4.phalloboards.info/login.html?return=aHR0cHM6Ly9qNC5waGFsbG9ib2FyZHMuaW5mby9nZW5lcmFsLWZvcnVtL2dlbmVyYWwtcGhhbGxvcGxhc3R5LWRpc2N1c3Npb24tYXJjaGl2ZS82OTc4NjM1LXJlZWQtdnMtcm9zZW50aGFsLmh0bWw/bWFya2Rvd249MQ==) or [Create an account](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) to join the conversation. ## Re: Reed VS Rosenthal 12 years 4 weeks ago [\#1283477618](#1283477618) - **[dcpimpin12](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html "View dcpimpin12's Profile")** - [![dcpimpin12's Avatar](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html "View dcpimpin12's Profile") - [ Offline](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html) - General - ![General](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/ranks/rank1.gif) - Posts: 316 - Thanks: 0 - [ ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/pms.html?task=new&recip=1982119) hands down go for dr brian Rosenthal and don't get lig cut and thickening sametime. most users report is better to get lig cut first and then later after u gain ur length for thickness. and ps: u don't need ur lig cut to gain length. u can gain length without it by just using a stretcher ad Hanging weights. Please [Log in](https://j4.phalloboards.info/login.html?return=aHR0cHM6Ly9qNC5waGFsbG9ib2FyZHMuaW5mby9nZW5lcmFsLWZvcnVtL2dlbmVyYWwtcGhhbGxvcGxhc3R5LWRpc2N1c3Npb24tYXJjaGl2ZS82OTc4NjM1LXJlZWQtdnMtcm9zZW50aGFsLmh0bWw/bWFya2Rvd249MQ==) or [Create an account](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) to join the conversation. ## Re: Reed VS Rosenthal 12 years 4 weeks ago [\#1283478200](#1283478200) - **[dcpimpin12](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html "View dcpimpin12's Profile")** - [![dcpimpin12's Avatar](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html "View dcpimpin12's Profile") - [ Offline](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/1982119-dcpimpin12.html) - General - ![General](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/ranks/rank1.gif) - Posts: 316 - Thanks: 0 - [ ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/pms.html?task=new&recip=1982119) i found this on dr reed [ www.susans.org/Sex\_Reassignment\_Surgery/MTF\_Surgeons/1467.html](http://www.susans.org/Sex_Reassignment_Surgery/MTF_Surgeons/1467.html) Please [Log in](https://j4.phalloboards.info/login.html?return=aHR0cHM6Ly9qNC5waGFsbG9ib2FyZHMuaW5mby9nZW5lcmFsLWZvcnVtL2dlbmVyYWwtcGhhbGxvcGxhc3R5LWRpc2N1c3Npb24tYXJjaGl2ZS82OTc4NjM1LXJlZWQtdnMtcm9zZW50aGFsLmh0bWw/bWFya2Rvd249MQ==) or [Create an account](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) to join the conversation. ## Re: Reed VS Rosenthal 12 years 4 weeks ago [\#1283477754](#1283477754) - **[dba256](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html "View dba256's Profile")** - [![dba256's Avatar](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/core/svg/person.svg)](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html "View dba256's Profile") Topic Author - [ Offline](https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/user/3184854-dba256.html) - General - ![General](https://j4.phalloboards.info/media/kunena/ranks/rank1.gif) - Posts: 2 - Thanks: 0 - [ ](https://j4.phalloboards.info/pms.html?task=new&recip=3184854) > dcpimpin12 wrote: hands down go for dr brian Rosenthal and don't get lig cut and thickening sametime. most users report is better to get lig cut first and then later after u gain ur length for thickness. and ps: u don't need ur lig cut to gain length. u can gain length without it by just using a stretcher ad Hanging weights. Thanks for responding dcpimpin12! I have heard a lot of good things about Dr. Rosenthal and his work, but I personally know a few people that has had success with Reed as well which is why I've been having trouble deciding. Have you gotten those procedures done with Rosenthal? If so, how was the process and how were your results? Please [Log in](https://j4.phalloboards.info/login.html?return=aHR0cHM6Ly9qNC5waGFsbG9ib2FyZHMuaW5mby9nZW5lcmFsLWZvcnVtL2dlbmVyYWwtcGhhbGxvcGxhc3R5LWRpc2N1c3Npb24tYXJjaGl2ZS82OTc4NjM1LXJlZWQtdnMtcm9zZW50aGFsLmh0bWw/bWFya2Rvd249MQ==) or [Create an account](https://j4.phalloboards.info/register.html) to join the conversation. Main Forums ## Schema ```json { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "BreadcrumbList", "itemListElement": [ { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 1, "name": "Home", "item": "https://j4.phalloboards.info" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 2, "name": "General Forum", "item": "https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum.html" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 3, "name": "PhalloBoards 2.0 Archived Content (Posting Locked & Read-Only)", "item": "https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/archived-content-from-version-2-0-read-only.html" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 4, "name": "General Phalloplasty Discussion (2.0 Archive)", "item": "https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/general-phalloplasty-discussion-archive.html" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 5, "name": "Reed VS Rosenthal", "item": "https://j4.phalloboards.info/general-forum/general-phalloplasty-discussion-archive/6978635-reed-vs-rosenthal.html" } ] } ```