Well if you put a sleeve on and it was a non factor I'd say it's not a big deal to her. Don't read into it too much.
I've been with a few different women because my wife and I are swingers and while I have gotten some decent feedback, nothing has been super great. Although one lady said I had the fattest
Dick she's ever seen, but besides from her.....nothing.
Point is, you and I both know your exceed average by far, what else can you do?